A controversial statement signed by dozens of Israeli doctors condoning the bombing of hospitals in Gaza has exposed deep divides within Israel’s healthcare system. It highlights the barriers facing Palestinian physicians who want to speak out against the endorsement of attacks on medical facilities and loss of civilian life.
The Incendiary Statement
The statement in question encouraged the military to eliminate terrorism “in any way” even if it meant bombing hospitals serving as “terrorist headquarters.” Though some viewed this as a legitimate stance, many were disturbed by doctors advocating attacks on medical facilities likely to kill healthcare workers and patients.
Six Palestinian doctors working in Israel decried the statement in an anonymous piece published in Al Jazeera. They lambasted the hypocrisy, racism and militarism they feel is embedded in the Israeli health system.
Muted Within the Ranks
These doctors described facing backlash for questioning Israeli military policy. They cannot advocate peaceful solutions without jeopardizing their jobs and safety.
“We cannot engage in any intellectual or moral conversation about the war. We are expected to condemn Hamas and join the patriotic Israeli military frenzy, while watching silently our Jewish colleagues cheering for the killing of innocent Palestinian civilians and endorsing the tightening of the blockade,” the doctors wrote.
Driving to work each day, they hear about the mounting death toll in Gaza and the West Bank. But in the hospitals and clinics where they work, the Palestinian doctors feel forced into silence.
“Jewish Supremacy in Life and Death”
“We have been forced to live in a coercive environment where Palestinian death is normalised and often celebrated, but Israeli Jewish death is seen as a tragedy that cannot be accepted and necessitates revenge,” the physicians stated.
They described this dynamic as “Jewish supremacy in life and death” now so ingrained that it reflects complicity from the Western world and its medical institutions.
Barred From Volunteering or Speaking Out
The doctors also cannot provide volunteer medical services to Palestinian civilians injured in airstrikes. Nor can they speak out against the civilian casualties and infrastructure damage without jeopardizing their careers.
“Not only are we barred from volunteering to provide medical aid to the innocent Palestinian civilians, but we are also not allowed to speak up against those state crimes without risking our jobs and safety,” the statement emphasized.
Quoting the Anonymous Doctors:
“We want this letter to serve as an apology to our Palestinian people and colleagues in the Gaza Strip, exposing our profound powerlessness and complete impotence. We and the world have failed you.”
History of Doctors Opposing War and Colonialism
The doctors pointed to the medical community’s long history of opposing war, from Vietnam to Iraq. They noted many American doctors lobbied against invading Iraq and Afghanistan after 9/11, understanding it would claim more innocent lives.
“But we are also aware that the majority of our fellow Israeli Jewish colleagues are on the opposite side of this urge to protect civilians, as the entire Israeli health system has been mobilized to join the war effort and support it,” the statement asserted.
Rather than prevent war and promote peace, the doctors insist the Israeli health system actively enables military operations.
Doctors Apologize for Their Powerlessness
In the final paragraph, the physicians apologized for their inability to speak out or provide medical assistance. They blamed “profound powerlessness and complete impotence” and wrote, “We and the world have failed you,” addressing Palestinians in Gaza.
Reporting Under Pseudonyms
The doctors issued their critique anonymously, fearing consequences within Israel’s healthcare system for opposing war and occupation. Their letter exposes shocking divisions in the medical community and restrictions on humanitarian aid and free speech for Palestinian professionals.
The Bigger Picture
This controversy highlights serious concerns about the weaponization of healthcare amidst warfare. Attacking medical facilities and targeting civilian populations violate international humanitarian law. Yet human rights groups have accused both Hamas and Israeli forces of committing war crimes during clashes in Gaza.
On one hand, statements like the one from the Israeli doctors seem to sanction violence against protected medical sites. But the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project found only 4% of Palestinian rocket attacks targeted civilian infrastructure in 2021. The vast majority aimed at open or military areas.
Questionable Military Tactics
Still, Israel insists its strikes aim to hamper Hamas’ military operations. But human rights advocates argue the resulting humanitarian crisis amounts to illegal collective punishment of Gazan civilians. Critical voices also question the efficacy of hardline military tactics for achieving long-term peace and security.
Calls for International Intervention
With civilian casualties mounting, groups like Amnesty International have called for international intervention. They demand accountability for potential war crimes and human rights violations by all parties. But so far, efforts to broker a ceasefire or reach a diplomatic solution have stalled.
The Human Toll
Caught in the crosshairs are civilians on both sides seeking shelter from the violence. Among them are doctors struggling to save lives amidst damaged hospitals and dwindling medical supplies. Their plight spotlights the urgent need for humanitarian protections in conflict zones.
Yet the divisions exposed among Israeli physicians demonstrate the significant barriers facing those who wish to speak out. For Palestinian doctors, maintaining silence allows suffering and loss of life to continue. But vocal opposition could derail their careers or personal safety.
An Intractable Conflict
What is clear is the intractable nature of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Core issues regarding sovereignty, security, human rights and mutual recognition remain unresolved. Within this fraught landscape, even physicians cannot separate politics from the practice of medicine. Their competing loyalties reflect the complex pressures shaping discourse about the crisis.
But the scale of civilian casualties also underscores the costs of inaction. All parties must acknowledge their shared humanity and moral imperative to protect the fundamental right to health, safety and dignity. Though the path forward remains uncertain, these goals should unite all those hoping to heal long-standing divisions.
The doctors’ statement exposes deep polarization among Israeli physicians, sharp restrictions on Palestinian colleagues and serious ethical questions about health worker roles amid warfare. Their message reinforces calls to safeguard medical neutrality and speak out against loss of civilian life. Achieving a just peace requires those within medicine to lead by promoting compassion and human rights.
Stay up to date on this developing story and other global news by subscribing to our newsletter. Unbiased, in-depth journalism requires resources. Together, we can seek facts and pursue truth.
