Monday, February 26, 2024

Legal Blow to Donald Trump: Ordered to Pay $400,000 in Legal Fees to New York Times and Reporters

HomePoliticsLegal Blow to Donald Trump: Ordered to Pay $400,000 in Legal Fees...

New York – In a decisive legal setback, former President Donald Trump has been ordered to pay nearly $400,000 in attorneys’ fees to The New York Times and three investigative reporters after an unsuccessful lawsuit he filed against them over a 2018 story detailing his family’s wealth and tax practices.

Manhattan Judge Robert Reed ruled on Friday that Trump must compensate the newspaper and journalists Susanne Craig, David Barstow and Russell Buettner for legal costs associated with defending themselves against Trump’s libel case, which accused them of being motivated by “personal vendetta” in their reporting.

The judge dismissed the newspaper and reporters from the lawsuit back in May. But Trump’s related claim against his estranged niece Mary Trump, alleging she violated a confidentiality agreement by providing the reporters with tax records, is still pending.

The New York Times story in question drew on more than 100,000 pages of confidential financial documents, including Fred Trump’s tax returns, to investigate how Donald Trump and his father avoided millions in gift and inheritance taxes over the years through various schemes, including setting up a shell company and undervaluing assets.

>>Related  How Did Alexei Navalny, Russian Opposition Leader and Putin Critic, Die in Prison at Age 47?

Mary Trump was eventually revealed as the source for the trove of financial records. Her “tell-all” book published in 2020 chronicled her experience being part of the Trump family and deciding to assist the Times’ investigation.

Lawyers for the Gray Lady celebrated Judge Reed’s latest decision as a victory for press freedom and a warning for those who try to silence journalists through frivolous litigation. The anti-SLAPP statute in New York is intended to deter such lawsuits.

“The court has sent a message that people cannot use the judicial system to chill journalists from scrutinizing public figures,” said Times spokesperson Danielle Rhoads Ha.

But Trump’s attorney Alina Habba expressed disappointment that the newspaper and reporters were let off the hook, stating they remain resolute in pursuing claims against Mary Trump over her alleged breach of contract.

>>Related  Democrats Flip New York House Seat in Rebuke of GOP’s Santos and Narrow Majority

This is just the latest episode in Trump’s long-running battle against the “fake news” media, which he often decries as biased, dishonest and out to get him. However, the courts have consistently ruled against the former president’s attempts to intimidate or punish journalists and news organizations for unflattering coverage through libel litigation.

Constitutional law experts argue Trump fundamentally misunderstands the extremely high bar for public figures like himself to prove defamation against the free press. But the former real estate mogul-turned-politician has never been one to back down from a fight.

During his presidency, Trump repeatedly threatened to “open up libel laws” to make it easier to sue news outlets. He filed numerous lawsuits against media companies, few of which have succeeded.

>>Related  Indonesia Election: Subianto Declares Victory, But Can He Avoid Runoff?

In a high-profile defamation case against writer E. Jean Carroll, who accused Trump of sexual assault in the 1990s, his DNA was recently obtained pursuant to court order. Trump tried to delay providing a sample to match against evidence Carroll says she has from a dress she wore during the alleged encounter.

Critics condemned Trump’s lawsuit against his niece as a similar attempt to abuse the courts and intimidate detractors. Mary Trump maintains the action is entirely retaliatory, designed to chill free speech critical of her famous relative, who has a long history of trying to use non-disclosure agreements and lawsuits to silence unfavorable press coverage and former associates.

With Judge Reed’s latest ruling, the former president has once again been reminded that even the brute force of America’s litigious legal system has its limits when it comes to his war against the free press.

Mezhar Alee
Mezhar Alee
Mezhar Alee is a prolific author who provides commentary and analysis on business, finance, politics, sports, and current events on his website Opportuneist. With over a decade of experience in journalism and blogging, Mezhar aims to deliver well-researched insights and thought-provoking perspectives on important local and global issues in society.

Latest Post

Related Posts